Shop for New Orleans Saints gear at Fanatics.com

New Rule Sparks Sexist Controversy

Let me begin this by sharing with you a comment by a reader from another site regarding the new NFL rule concerning hits. This is what he posted:

Frank says:
“As concerns the new rules concerning hits, I think the league has gone too far. I agree with Matt Millen though he could not say what was on his mind because it wouldn.t be politcally correct. People are influencing the game who don’t know what the game intaills (women) and the game will eventually be destroyed. Everything seems to be changed when ever they give their imput concerning what men do or have. Just as in the case of locker rooms with the Ines case. If thing are equal men should be allowed in the womens locker room as well. or no one should be allowed in any locker room.”

Now I usually don’t even waste time or energy on such ignorance as exhibited by this person, but his comment disturbed me, even more than it offended me, in large part because this fellow was far from being alone in his ludicrous assumption that somehow, women are behind the NFL’s new rule regarding unnecessary roughness. And to further state that women don’t know what the game entails and that we are destroying the game, only shows that this guy’s disdain for women has clearly clouded his judgment, along with that of all who agree with his theory. For him or anyone else to think that women could possibly influence the decisions of the NFL–a fiercely male-dominated industry–is about as ridiculous a notion as any I’ve ever heard. 

As football fans, we can all appreciate a good, hard-hitting game.  After all, those “train wrecks” are what we look for on replay reels week after week.  And as a woman, I do understand that football is a violent game in which players are not only trained to hit as hard as they can, but they are expected to do it or look for another line of work.  I accept that because football has been around a lot longer than I have.  When I came to know anything about it, it was all about the toughest of the tough exerting their will in order to win–and the rules are quite a bit more relaxed now than they were back then.  It was my personal choice to become a fan of something those less-enthusiastic than I have often termed “barbaric” and all that it entails.  Football has never been a sport for the squirmish (male or female) and it never will be. 

These new rules are being put in place to protect the lives of the players, not to pacify some phantom group of women somewhere who want to turn football into a “wimpy” sport.  By looking out for its players upon implementing these rules, the NFL is protecting the integrity of the game by showing that it will not condone malicious intent aimed against any of its players.  For those who prefer to dredge up what football used to be like in terms of physicality and toughness, I’d suggest examining the health of a player from that era to see how his health faired after his NFL career was over.  I’d be willing to bet that the majority of those players would’ve preferred to do things differently had they known then what they know now.  It’s just like with anything else, with the passage of time comes knowledge.  Those long-term football-related injuries of the game’s pioneers are what has prompted the league to take the actions it has up to this point.

I’d be less than honest if I said I’m not awed by the mere sight and sound of those hard hits when I see them on highlights after the game.  Heck–I love ’em!  It wouldn’t be football if you didn’t have those.  In fact, I’ll go a little further in saying I don’t think it’s fair to the players to train them to play a certain way then punish them for doing so.  On that order, I can understand all the discontent surrounding this newest and other such rules aimed at protecting players.  What protects some limits others.  Still and all, I would hope that  no one in his or her right mind would wish a life-threatening or life-altering injury on anyone just to win a game.  It should never be that serious.  Now I want you to hear me loud and clear when I say that I’m just as passionate about the game of football as my husband, my son, and my brothers are and I have been so my whole life.  I’m all for hard hitting, smash-mouth style of play on the field.  But don’t accuse me of trying to destroy the game I love so dearly because I care more about what happens to the players (no matter who they play for) than I do about being able to have bragging rights.  Winning is great, but human life is sacred.   Some men somewhere have had to feel the same way or else the rules would’ve never changed.


Enjoyed this post?
Subscribe to Saints Gab via RSS Feed or E-mail and receive daily news updates from us!

Submit to Digg  Stumble This Story  Share on Twitter  Post on Facebook  Post on MySpace  Add to del.icio.us  Bark It Up  Submit to Reddit  Fave on Technorati

6 Responses to “New Rule Sparks Sexist Controversy”

  1. nolalola504 says:

    I had no idea that people were claiming women somehow had something to do with these rules – I think if anyone, players unions and managers have more to do with it, to protect their investments.

    To think that, as you said, a largely male-dominated & supported organization would be swayed by “hand-wringing women” is insane. I am a woman, and I wouldn’t want my husband or son to play in the NFL, but I LOVE football and know that it is a seriously physical sport. Do I think that James Harrison should be in big trouble for the two massive helmet hits he pulled during the Steelers game on Sunday? Of course. But so do all the men who watched the game with me.

    • Thank you so much for this comment. This issue should in no way have ever become one about sex. For anyone to think that women are in any way influencing these decisions to protect the players is ridiculous. It just goes to show how ignorance breeds ignorance. I was just really shocked to see just how many others in that small space were in agreement with this guy. Just when you think we’ve come so far, you read something like this.

      • nolalola504 says:

        We know it’s bad for us, but we can’t help reading the comments! I think sometimes, since it’s so anonymous, people make ignorant comments online when they may not really believe 100% in what they say (at least that’s what I tell myself to stay calm). However, like you said, in this case it wasn’t just that one guy. Still, what are they going to do? They can’t stop us from loving football! We just won’t be watching the games with them. 🙂

        • I so agree with you! We don’t need anyone’s permission to watch football. The ignorance of a few idiots will not ruin my joy. It’s just really sad though that in this world, there’s still the attitude–when all else fails, blame women. But we have every right to watch and love football as anybody else. Thanks so very much for your comment. I really do appreciate it.

  2. Marylyn says:

    There’s not much more to add to something that is as complete as what she wrote. So I’ll just say, Thanks.

Leave a Reply